Southington Personal Injury Firm
Client-Focused, Results Driven Over 30 Year of Proven Legal Experience

Anthony A. Sheffy

Connecticut Insurance Defense and Personal Injury Attorney

Anthony Sheffy

Phone: (860) 200-3443 ext. 106
Fax: (860) 620-9348

Anthony Sheffy is the founding partner of Sheffy, Mazzaccaro, DePaolo & DeNigris, L.L.P., which is located centrally in Southington, Connecticut. He has taken insurance, personal injury and commercial jury verdicts in state and federal court on behalf of both businesses and individuals.

Tony has written and lectured on topics ranging from the fundamentals of presenting civil jury cases for lawyers new to the practice to advanced evidence techniques for attorneys experienced in the courtroom. He has presented televised seminars on the trial of traumatic brain injury cases.

Tony has been honored by his peers with an AV* rating from Martindale Hubbell . He has been inducted into the Order of Justitia by the Litigation Counsel of America consisting of the top 1% of all lawyers in America, a Fellow of the American Bar Foundation, designated as a Top 100 Lawyers in America, and recognized in the area of plaintiff’s personal injury by Connecticut Super Lawyers® since 2011.

Tony has been recognized for his work with local non-profit organizations receiving the Southington-Cheshire YMCA's Person of the Year Award. He is a founding director of the Southington Education Foundation, past Chair of the Southington Chamber of Commerce (where he remains as legal counsel), and past president of the Southington United Way. He presently serves as a Board Member of the Charter Oak State College Foundation and the Southington YMCA. He is legal counsel to the Southington Chamber.

Mr. Sheffy earned his B.S. degree in combined music and physics from Lebanon Valley College (1985); and his J.D. degree, magna cum laude, from Western New England School of Law (1988) where he was selected for the law review. He is admitted to the bar for Connecticut state courts and the Federal District Court for the State of Connecticut and pro hoc vice in the State of RI.

*AV Preeminent is a certification mark of Reed Elsevier Properties Inc., used in accordance with the Martindale-Hubbell certification procedures, standards and policies. Martindale-Hubbell is the facilitator of a peer review rating process. Ratings reflect the confidential opinions of members of the Bar and the judiciary. Martindale-Hubbell ratings fall into two categories - legal ability and general ethical standards.

*The Selection Criteria for the designation by Connecticut Super Lawyers, as well as statistics regarding the section process can be found here:

Practice Areas

To get in touch with Mr. Sheffy, please call Sheffy, Mazzaccaro, DePaolo & DeNigris, L.L.P. at (860) 200-3443.

Our Commitment to Excellence

  • Million Dollar Advocates Forum
  • Super Lawyers
  • AV Preeminent Rated
  • American Bar Foundation
  • LCA Proven Trial Lawyers

Client Testimonials

  • “You put everything in terms I could understand and what was expected by both parties, which definitely made the transaction smooth.”

    Candy C.

  • “Highly recommended!”

    Uncion D.

  • “We are looking forward to working with you on future business …”

    Mike P., Columbia Package Store

  • “Your dedication to your profession is truly astonishing.”

    Pauline S.

  • “Office is very personable.”

    Cindy C.

Knowledge. Experience. Success.

See Why We Are The Right Choice
  • Experience

    Our firm has over 30 years of proven experience.

  • Compassion

    We truly care about you and take a personal interest in your case.

  • Results

    We have collected millions of dollars in compensation for our clients.

  • Tailored-Approach

    We customize our strategy to obtain the best possible outcome.